4.8/5 - (45 votes)

At some weddings, one guest went home with a very particular souvenir: a small box holding a slice of the groom’s cake. The unmarried woman who received it was not supposed to eat it. She was meant to sleep with it under her pillow.

That sweet superstition belongs to a tradition many couples have never heard of, even though it is usually traced back to Victorian England. Here is the story of the groom’s cake, and of the curiously named “wedding breakfast” where it was sometimes served.

A second cake with a richer personality

Two cakes at one wedding is not a new idea. For part of the 17th century, weddings featured a large white pound cake for the bride, white symbolizing purity, alongside a smaller, darker and richer fruitcake for the groom.

The groom’s cake as a named tradition took shape in Victorian England. It was often richer than the bride’s cake, because stronger flavors such as chocolate, fruitcake and alcohol were considered more masculine at the time. Victorian groom’s cakes were heavy, dense fruitcakes, and a characteristic recipe was published in The British Baker in 1897.

Over time, flour cakes, either white or chocolate, replaced fruitcake as the most popular choice.

How the American South kept the tradition alive

In England, the groom’s cake eventually faded out of the main event. It found a lasting home elsewhere: brought over from Britain by colonists, it is today a tradition most popular in the Southeastern United States.

The Southern groom’s cake was traditionally a fruitcake soaked in dark liquor, especially in Virginia, since the white-iced bride’s cake was considered too light for the groom. Chocolate groom’s cakes became popular in the late 19th century, and today the flavor is open: carrot cake, red velvet, or even cheesecake.

See also  Candid wedding photos were often staged after the ceremony until the 1970s

It is usually served at a separate table from the wedding cake, as a second flavor choice for guests. In some regions, it appears instead as a dessert at the rehearsal dinner.

Groom’s cakes are often decorated to reflect the groom’s hobbies or interests, such as golfing, fishing, hunting or other sports. Movie fans may remember the famous scene in Steel Magnolias (1989), with its red velvet groom’s cake shaped like a giant armadillo.

The slice under the pillow

Back to that little box. One tradition was to cut a piece of the groom’s cake, place it in a small box and present it to an unmarried woman attending the wedding. She was not expected to eat the cake, but rather to put it under her pillow.

Superstition held that this would help her find a husband. It is a gentle reminder that wedding cakes have always carried wishes for the guests as well as for the couple.

Why the wedding breakfast is rarely eaten in the morning

The groom’s cake could be served at a wedding reception or at a wedding breakfast, a phrase still used in British English for the feast given to the newlyweds and their guests after the wedding. Nowadays it is not normally a morning meal, nor does it look like a typical breakfast, which makes the name a little confusing.

A popular explanation points to pre-Reformation times, when the wedding service was usually a Mass. The couple would have fasted beforehand in order to receive Communion, and afterwards the priest blessed and handed round wine, cakes and sweetmeats: a literal “break fast”. It is a lovely story, but the phrase cannot be shown to date back earlier than the first half of the 19th century. The Oxford English Dictionary records no use before 1850, though it appeared at least as far back as 1838.

See also  Before the chuppah stood on four poles, it was a real room for the couple

A London guide from 1880, Party-giving on Every Scale, already observed that the orthodox wedding breakfast “might more properly be termed a ‘Wedding Luncheon'”. Fifty years earlier, the author added, luncheon was not a recognised meal, even in the wealthiest families.

Bringing a groom’s cake to your own wedding

If the idea makes you smile, a groom’s cake is a tradition you can shape entirely around your couple. It can be any flavor, served beside the main cake or at the rehearsal dinner, and decorated around a hobby your partner loves.

And if a single friend is on your guest list, a small boxed slice to tuck under the pillow is a sweet nod to this old custom.