4.7/5 - (46 votes)

When researchers Broude and Greene studied 142 cultures around the world, they found that 130 of them have at least some elements of arranged marriage. That is a lot more than most of us would guess, and it says something warm about how weddings have always worked: families usually care who joins them.

Arranged marriage was once the world’s default

Arranged marriages were the norm throughout the world until the 18th century. Parents, grandparents or trusted friends usually took the lead in finding a match. In France, they stayed normal until the Second World War.

Migration carried the custom further. Among Japanese-American immigrants, some brides were known as “picture brides” because the couple knew each other only through exchanged photographs before the wedding day.

It is a spectrum, not a single custom

Scholars sort marriages into four broad groups, and the differences between them are about who chooses and who can say no:

Researchers Gary Lee and Lorene Stone suggest that most adult marriages in recent history fall somewhere between consensual arranged and autonomous. Marriage, after all, is a social institution, and very few couples marry in a bubble.

Free consent is the dividing line

An arranged marriage is not the same thing as a forced one. In a forced marriage, one or both partners do not consent, and the United Nations condemns it. Jennifer Burns of Anti-Slavery Australia puts the difference clearly: “Arranged marriages are widely practised in Australia… but ultimately, the couple decides whether they want to marry. A forced marriage is the opposite.”

Matchmaking is still alive today

In Japan, the traditional miai is making a comeback. A matchmaker, called a nakodo, helps families and the couple meet, and the pair typically meets three times before deciding whether to get engaged.

See also  Many Thai and Chinese families return part of the bride price to the couple

In India, the matchmaker is traditionally a family friend or a distant relative. They act as both a scout, looking for a good match in the community, and a negotiator between the two families. They are usually not paid, but often receive gifts from the families.

Maybe the gap is smaller than it looks

Willoughby suggests that arranged marriages can work because they remove some of the anxiety of finding a spouse. Families offer an outside view of a person’s history and compatibility, and they often help with money, housing and childcare.

Michael Rosenfeld argues that the difference between autonomous and arranged marriages is empirically small. Most of us already choose partners who are similar in background, age, interests and social class, which are the very things parents would have screened for anyway. Whether a couple met through a friend, an app or an aunt, what counts is that both said yes freely.